Skip to content
Smart Arena

When the Blacksmith Has a Million Detractors, I Stand as Among Them.

The moment I discovered that Clint from the beloved farming sim had been announced as one of the two bachelors in the forthcoming 1.7 update, I exclaimed with disbelief, “That incel?!” The news consumed me for the rest of the evening — if Clint has a legion of critics (and he does), I am one of them; were he to have no haters, it means I've departed this earthly realm. Yet, with some reflection, I’ve come to see that perhaps this is precisely the intent — there is no character in greater need of a second chance than Clint.

The Root of the Dislike

Pelican Town's blacksmith has attracted a lot of ire over the years, primarily because of his fixation on Emily, another marriage candidate. During his early cutscenes, he asks the player for their advice on women, then behaves with painful awkwardness in front of Emily, as she serves him in the saloon, only to moan to the player that he’s “doomed.” He frequently comes off as pessimistic, desperate, and borderline creepy — to many, he embodies a classic “nice guy” who gets angry at even the slightest perceived rejection.

A Common Reaction

The response to this part of the 1.7 update was far from unique. Players have voiced a myriad of complaints, disappointment over other characters who could have been picked instead, and endless jokes following the announcement. One social media user remarked, “Picture finishing a terrible day of your life and learning Clint is now someone you can marry in Stardew Valley.”

A Spark of Potential

Nevertheless, part of the conversation about this hasn’t been so bleak and — reluctantly — makes a few good points. Some fans have likened the prospect of reforming Clint to that of Haley. Haley starts as extremely mean initially, but warms up through friendship, a process some have referred to as “improving Haley so she sucks less to be around.” Clint shares a lot of that same potential, but with a crucial distinction: he gives a lot of players feel uncomfortable.

Image: ConcernedApe

The Uneasy Feeling

I’ve personally always found Haley’s early rudeness more palatable than Clint’s unrequited fixation with a woman who doesn’t reciprocate, and many other players appear to share the same. It's difficult to pinpoint a finger on precisely why — perhaps it’s just a situation many fans can relate to, giving them a stronger gut response to Clint. This ick factor inherent to Clint certainly adds an additional challenge in him being seen as an appealing marriage candidate, but that might be just another reason the character is in dire need of redemption.

A Hint of Understanding

It must be said that, despite how often I’ve shouted about how much Clint needs to change his ways, he does inspire a degree of sympathy. Perhaps not when the notorious bush-hiding incident, but overall, he does seem like a melancholy, isolated man. A fan wrote, “Clint is someone looking for someone who will choose him back, and this is what being romanceable offers him.”

A Role for Redemption

The blacksmith's upcoming romance path might not appeal to every kind of Stardew Valley player, but it serves a purpose. As dubious as I am about ever consider him as spouse material, the game's creator is a wonderful writer known for adding layers to all the residents of the valley. Similar to previous expansions, the new version seems to be a substantial content drop crafted with care at its heart, and Clint’s development is unlikely to be being done flippantly. Perhaps through this new chance at love, fans can finally put their hate for him aside and place it where it truly belongs — toward Pierre.

Written by

James Gonzalez

Elara Vance is a tech journalist and innovation analyst with over a decade of experience covering emerging technologies and digital trends.

Smart Arena

Type to search articles.